Showing posts with label Education. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Education. Show all posts

Thursday, December 16, 2010

Rick Levin for NEC Director

Several news sites are reporting that Yale President Rick Levin is one of the three finalists to replace Larry Summers as Assistant to the President for Economic Policy and Director of the National Economic Council.

Despite being two baby boomer Jewish economists who have run two of America's top universities, Levin and Summers could not be more different. Summers while many accounts a difficult manager is also one of the top economists in the world. (He ranks at a super-human 17, surrounded by numerous Nobel Laurates).

Levin, by contrast, is a spectacular manager, having personally trained the presidents of Oxford, Cambridge, MIT, Duke, Wellesley and the former president of Penn. (In a further comparison to Summers' ill perceived comments about women in science, four of these Levin acolytes are women.) That said, Levin doesn't even rank in the top 10% of economists, in part since he has served almost the past 20 years in administration, first as dean of Yale's Graduate School and then as University President.

Since the NEC is not a large government department or agency, and since Levin's skills are more as a manager than as an economist, perhaps he would be better suited for another position in the administration, should one open up. Unlike former President Bush, who for the first 6 years of his presidency diminished the importance of his Treasury Secretaries, President Obama has put Secretary Geithner front and center with his full support. Given the sprawling nature of that department, maybe it would be a better place for Levin.

As for NEC chair, how about Alan Krueger? Then again, he's already at his two-year public service leave limit from Princeton, and so he'd have to give up his tenure. That in itself is a topic for another time.

Tuesday, September 1, 2009

No more Reading Rainbow

Butterfly in the sky / I can go twice as high / take a look / it's in a book / Reading Rainbow.

Evening singing that to myself now makes me smile. Some of my happiest moments at as a child were watching this show. Amazing stories about exciting books. LeVar Burton in all of his warmth and joy about learning. Kids getting to give their own opinion, unvarnished or scripted by adults.

Well, it's over. PBS is shifting funding toward programs that teach how to read, instead of teaching why. Some blame the Bush administration.

I'm reminded of the great quotation from Mr. Holland's Opus:
Vice Principal Wolters: I care about these kids just as much as you do. And if I'm forced to choose between Mozart and reading and writing and long division, I choose long division.

Glenn Holland: Well, I guess you can cut the arts as much as you want, Gene. Sooner or later, these kids aren't going to have anything to read or write about.

Monday, August 24, 2009

Academic Earth

So, it's late Sunday afternoon in Japan. I'm exhausted from a day of sightseeing around the city. I'm saving the novels I brought for two-day chags (Jewish holidays). I'm saving my West Wing DVDs for airplane flights. Hulu won't work outside the US. All of my satellite TV channels are in Japanese. And, it's not time for dinner yet.

This is when I discovered Academic Earth. Richard Ludlow, a bright young Yale grad, realized that many universities were video taping their best lectures and courses and putting them online for free for the public. But, to find them, you'd have to know which universities were doing this, and even then would only get a random smattering of courses. There was no way to find all of the ones on a particular topic.

Academic Earth serves as an aggregator of all of this content. Plus, it lets you rate each one, so that overtime you'll be able to see which Game Theory or Political Philosophy lecture is the best. You can even download the syllabus and exams in some cases.

I just watched Barry Nalebuff's "Why Not?" lecture on entrepeneurship, and am starting Benjamin Polack's Game Theory course. Both are worth watching.

Sunday, August 23, 2009

Publishing in an academic journal

In case you're thinking about academia (I am), you probably should read this horrific account of trying to publish a comment.

Monday, June 2, 2008

World Science Festival a Big Hit

This past weekend's World Science Festival in New York was a huge success, drawing well over 100,000 people to an outdoor festival and 46 other sold out events. One of the best was Alan Alda's staged reading of the play QED, which Alda premiered on Broadway a few years ago, about the physicist Richard Feynman at the end of his life.

Read festival co-founded and Columbia Physics Professor Brian Greene in yesterday's NYT.

Wednesday, April 9, 2008

Urge Yale to influence China to peacefully resolve Tibet crisis

Yale sophomore Eli Bildner has been building a campaign urging Yale to use its newfound influence with China (from recently ramped up collaborative programs with univerisites and government official) to speak out against human rights abuses in Tibet.

After two weeks, Levin et al. finally responded (http://www.yaledailynews.com/articles/view/24315). The work, however, is far from done. Please nudge Yale to keep up the pressure on China by signing Eli's petition at http://www.petitionspot.com/petitions/Yaletibet.

Tuesday, April 1, 2008

Cleaning up Bush's mess

Slate.com has a spectacular new ten-piece series on how to fix the damage the Bush administration has done. The first four pieces on education, technology, foreign policy, and the military are up.

Monday, March 31, 2008

Science education at Yale

Excellent piece in today's Yale Daily News encouraging science and math study at Yale. The author makes the point that many Yalies have the mathematical and scientific background from high school to study those subjects in college, yet take a defeatist attitude and shy away from those classes.

The article avoids the even more important point: that a strong background in science and math can immensely help graduating seniors in the job markets, in a wide variety of scientific and business fields.

Wednesday, March 12, 2008

Ignore college statistics

Grant Calder, Director of College Counseling at Friends' Central School's argues that it's a great time to apply to college, since "The numbers of college applicants are up, but so are the numbers of spaces, programs, scholarships, and opportunities in general for all sorts of students to study and earn an undergraduate degree."

Tuesday, January 22, 2008

Harvard/Yale aid reforms is not a letdown

Columbia's former dean of students and director of American studies argue in today's New York Times that Harvard and Yale's increase of financial aid to upper middle class families (though with household incomes over $120,000) is a "letdown".

The authors are simply wrong. They conflate two related, but distinct, problems in American higher education. The first is that poor, working class, and middle class families cannot afford to send their children to college. At America's richest universities, generous financial aid policies have gone a long way toward solving this problem. There is still a work to be done, but for families who literally do not make enough to pay their children's tuition bills, there is significant help. At Harvard and Yale in particular, recent changes in aid policy (favoring grants over loans, decreases in expected work study and summer contributions) are nearing the extinction of this problem.

The second problem, in many ways, is far worse. It is the problem that upper middle class families increasing simply cannot afford to spend $40,000 a year on one child's college education, and certainly cannot spend $80,000 a year for two children. This is a relatively new problem in America. Poor and middle class families have always had difficulty paying for hired education, and the trend since World War II has been overwhelmingly positive (at least, until recent years). On the other hand, up until the past decade or so, upper middle class families have been able to afford to send their children to the best colleges in the country. The departure from this is troubling.

Bright high school seniors should not have to choose between schools based on cost, no matter what their family income. In upper middle class families, financial aid has languished behind rising need, which, yes, does exist for those families. It is about time that America's universities are beginning to take notice. Harvard and Yale's desire to make college truly affordable to everyone is laudable.

Thursday, January 17, 2008

Arabic noun grammar

Mah Rabu's BZ has a great post about the complexities of Arabic noun gender and number.

Yale improves ethnic counselor program

It's about time that Yale decided to merge its freshman counselor program (basically R.A.s) with its ethnic counselor program (for only black, Hispanic, and Asian students). Yale has finally realized that every student has qualities that make him or her diverse (e.g. race, religion, national origin, family income), and that freshman counselors equipped with the tools to help students similar to (and different from) themselves is the best way to help a diverse freshman class integrate itself into the university.

Wednesday, January 16, 2008

Democrats fail to mention "Don't ask, don't tell"

In last night's Democratic presidential debate in Nevada, each candidate completely missed the point about why elite American colleges do not have ROTC programs:

NBC's TIM RUSSERT: …There's a federal statute on the books which says that, if a college or university does not provide space for military recruiters or provide a ROTC program for its students, it can lose its federal funding. Will you vigorously enforce that statute?

CLINTON: Yes, I will. You know, I think that the young men and women who voluntarily join our all-volunteer military are among the best of our country….

RUSSERT: Of the top 10 rated schools, Harvard, Yale, Columbia, Stanford, they do not have ROTC programs on campus. Should they?
CLINTON: Well, there are ways they can work out fulfilling that obligation. But they should certainly not do anything that either undermines or disrespects the young men and women who wish to pursue a military career.

RUSSERT: Senator Obama, same question. Will you vigorously enforce a statute which says colleges must allow military recruiters on campus and provide ROTC programs?

OBAMA: Yes….

RUSSERT: This statute's been on the books for some time, Senator. Will you vigorously enforce the statute to cut off federal funding to the school that does not provide military recruiters and a ROTC program?

EDWARDS: Yes, I will….

The reason these schools do not have ROTC programs (and fight military recruiters tooth and nail) is that the government's homophobic "Don't ask, don't tell" policy violates these universities anti-discrimination policies, which prohibit discrimination based on sexual orientation. If the government had ended "Don't ask, don't tell" after September 11, 2001, most of these schools would have immediately reinstated ROTC.

In a previous debate, all of the Democratic candidates (including Obama, Clinton, and Edwards) raised their hands in support of ending "Don't ask, don't tell." Yet all three failed to mention it as a strategy to returning ROTC to America's elite campuses. Hopefully this does not represent a shift in gay rights support for the Democratic presidential candidates.

Tuesday, January 15, 2008

U.S. Dominance in Science in Technology in Trouble

It's time that this country got serious about science and math education, with competitive funding for top teachers and funding for experiments and demonstrations.

Monday, January 14, 2008

Yale tops Harvard in Financial Aid Reform

Yale just announced financial aid reform that surpasses Harvard's, extending the "pay no more than 10% of your household income in tuition" to families that make between $180,000 and $200,000 a year, whereas Harvard caps it at $180,000.

The question is - what happens to familes that have household income of $210,000? Do they get the old formula, which would have given them $0 in finanicial aid?

Mom, let me sleep in

Excellent op-ed in the New York Times about why teenagers may be right when they want to sleep in.

Saturday, December 29, 2007

Plagiarism rampant in China

Excellent article on the lack of intellectual integrity in one of China's leading universities.

Monday, December 10, 2007

Harvard drastically changes aid policy

Harvard just announced a more than $20 million increase in financial aid.

Specifically:
  • Families that make between $120,000 and $180,000 per year will be asked to pay 10 percent of their yearly income in tuition
  • Families that make between $60,000 and $120,000 per year will pay between zero and ten percent of their yearly incomes in tuition
  • Home equity will also be eliminated from financial aid calculations
  • Financial aid will cease to include student loans, moving to only grants
This is pretty incredible. Let's see how Harvard's peers follow suit.

(For more info, see here.)

Monday, November 26, 2007

Creationism and science education

The New York Times magazine recently had an article about creationist geologies, whose mission is to prove that the physical history of the Earth exactly matches that of Genesis, using whatever means necessary to justify it. This reasoning involves construing scenarios where the great flood of Noah’s time created many of the rocks and fossils that otherwise would have taken millions of years to form, since those who take Genesis literally believe that the Earth is less than 10,000 years old.

The problem is that this analysis masquerade as a legitimize scientific method. The conclusions are already foregone, with absolutely no room for modification based on new evidence (as rewriting Genesis is hubristic blasphemy).

This kind of reasoning, whether about biology or geology, has serious ramification for our secondary school educational system. Believing something is true because G-d said so isn’t wrong or shameful. Teaching it in a secondary school science class that is supposed to be about reasoning and logic and objectivity is. Once we teach young students that they can hold fast to their conclusions by faith alone, and then selectively choose evidence that can support their beliefs, we’ve stopped teaching science, and started teaching religion. How can students develop the critical reasoning skills that they need to survive today’s competitive world if they’re taught dogma instead of science?

The most recent Lubavitcher Rebbe, Rabbi Menachem Schneerson, used to say that G-d put fossils on the Earth to test our faith. While faith in G-d has brought much strength and comfort to Americans, one must not get in the way of science education. The United States has already fallen too far behind its peers in science education. Religion should not make it worse.